All have significant value (at least xxa), however the exalted is outstanding (xxxa). Exalted 120-180a with bid war.
My bet would be exalted > spiked > ornate buckler > round > reinforced buckler.
This might or could heavily vary with individual interest.
In case you are on seller side: dont sell to PM, dont rush, put all for auction.
Look what the tide washed in :
nice tell schilt
no 4 & 6 have most value imo.
4 xxxe
6 few a maybe. Postnerf max q8 +5e is nice.
5, 8 and 9 I would merch.
Rest get what you can
would merch all. Potentially few e for the q9 15/50 ones
xxe range
i dont see this going for xx arms. Is 14% stance. Fow is still played and these things keep dropping.
chalice and gothic would definetly merch.
Effigy would put for sale. Maybe some ectos but the valuable times of effigies are over
echovald #1 dual ench: 60a
Ing: Hate Core Sin
gbp: 1-2a
Sunqua: 4-6a
Aegis demon: 10-15a, put for auction
Aegi pierce: 150-250e
Aegi slash: 150-250e
Gothic: 3-6a
Ornate buckler (q9?): 5-10a? Not sure
OB pierce: ~2-3a
OB slash: ~2-3a
bump
Looney thanks for the q9 20hex colossal pick and the nice conversation 
Still looking for q9 dual vamp colossal pick to complete the q9 set.
q10 Magmas Shield #7 - 100e
q9 Celestial Shield #2 - 1a
q9 Celestial Shield #3 - 200e
q9 Echovald #5 - 3a
nothing really valuable. 90%+ is merch and some stuff in xx e range that some of the less lazy posters after me might confirm.
Would be good to learn some basic principles of price checking so you save yourself and us time.
My reply to this thread is a solid start: List of exotic items wanted / items to merch
q10 Magmas Shield #7 - 100e
q9 Celestial Shield #2 - 1a
q9 Celestial Shield #3 - 120e
q9 Echovald #5 - 3a
q10 Magmas Shield #7 - 100e
q9 Celestial Shield #2 - 1a
q9 Celestial Shield #3 - 120e
q9 Echovald #5 - 2a
echo q9 dual ench 55a (choose one)
have gbp, broadsword, oni blade OS q9 +5e for sale
Gbp, zodiac sword also as q9 inscr
bladed dual ench 80e
200e fellblade
80e fellblade
Take what you can, hard sale 20-30e
bone staff ~20e
Plagueborns merch
bump.
Auction on flame artifact will end tomorrow (monday) 8pm CET if no other offers within 24h.
celestial few a
Echo 1: 20-30e, take what you can
Plagueborn: 50-1a to a collector of heartbreakers or plagueborns with some luck
Echo 2: 40-80e, high req, tactics and stance is not quite demanded
merch. Even as q9 would be hard sell
milita
Tall
Retract as they are not gold
from my own experience with selling these I say 100e to 1a.
