Display MoreAccording wiki (and my experience) after first finish u get the horsemans
I'm going to disagree with that
I had, in order:
- 1st run of the dungeon quest (The Dreamer and the Zealot) on NM (right after the round trip to find Duke).
- 2nd run in HM with the Horsemen (normal so far). Golds in the chest.
- 3rd run in HM, with the basic monsters, without the Horsemen. Purples in the chest.
Edit: Or, if someone in the group is doing it for the first time (leaves the dungeon after Duke, then joins a group for the HM at Piken Place), the Horsemen don't appear.
It’s a bit like the bug in the Pre dungeon, which duplicated NPCs and chests when someone in the group ran it for the first time, provided at least one other member had already run it.
Must have been someone in my party that had done it previously. It was my first time through on NM to get Althea and we had Horsemen.