From a retired player point of view, in 2018-2019, the market ladder was around:
- ~2500a: unded panda or unded IG or very nice henchman tonic
- ~1750a: ded panda or ded IG or unded MKG or regular henchman tonic
- ~1300a: reindeer tonic or ded MKG or ugly henchman tonic
I understand these prices are not accurate in today's market, but it's more about the ratio between items.
So, to me it seems crazy to consider a reindeer for an unded panda, it would've been almost two for one at the time.
But I guess it can always be shuffled around based on supply/demand.
Back then, there were 3 reindeers for sell for months in kamadan and no one wanted them