So you know when you have to read a post a few times to check you read it right the first few because it strikes a chord with you? Well that just happened to me.
@WFI:
You’re more right than I think you know. If I’m honest, I’m struggling a bit with my stance on this issue, and I find it intriguing that you have noticed. The last two and a half years since guru died and we started Legacy has seen my role change somewhat from just being a collector (albeit an outspoken one) to becoming some sort of ambassador for the community in general. And I’ll be honest - it’s not my natural role. I’m having to grow into it. But I am learning all the time, and I don’t always get it right. I have found myself in this position more through luck than judgement. I have been driving Legacy forward (financially and directionally too) since it started, and it has put me in positions I never imagined i’d find myself. I wanted to be known as a collector, and instead myself and Legacy have become entwined as one. I have established direct lines of communication with the Devs and other people at Anet, as well as other community elders, and by working with Kevin this little site has become more successful than we ever imagined. We are planning things that we never dreamed we might.
But that has meant I have had to change my approach gradually. And yes, I suopose I am trying to be an ambassador for the community, because I believe in it passionately and will do whatever I can to keep it alive. And I find myself in a position to directly influence and drive things forward. So to that end, I do feel I have to listen to both sides of every argument instead of just stubbornly asserting one position as I used to.
The issue around toolbox is unique however. I have never used it, so I don’t know it. But I know that large numbers of our community do. My old-Max head says it’s cheating - and my personal feelings back that up. But my ambassador head recognises that it has a large user base, and those guys are as much a part of our community as anyone else. So where does my opinion decide to go, given that I’m naturally torn? Well I have to be responsible because that is the position I find myself in. To follow my heart and call for Toolbox to be banned would certainly fit with old-Max, but community-Max has to take a whole community view. And I’m struggling a bit as I said.
The interesting part of all this is that Toolbox has filled the void caused by years of no development from Anet. Many of the features of Toolbox would likely have ended up being implemented into the game though evolution. So we find ourselves at a unique crossroads. Anet’s neglect caused Toolbox to be what it is today. And it would be tantamount to burying one’s head in the sand to think otherwise. And yet it doesn’t comply with the EULA. That’s the very definition of irony.
So you’re right. And you have noticed that I struggle with this role. I didn’t expect to still be in this position, but here we are. It’s evolving all the time, and I’ll continue to try and keep up with that.
I certainly don’t want Toolbox to divide the community. I spend all my energy trying to bring it all together somehow. To me, middle ground at this stage feels the right way to be going. But of course, I’m just a guy, same as any of us. And old-Max is having to evolve.